Four Holiday DVDs

Ah, the holiday season is upon us once again, and it is time to start
getting into that wintery, holiday mood. One of the typical ways that
families, including mine, get in the mood is to put on those favorite
holiday movies, pop up some popcorn, build a roaring fire, and have a
family movie night or two.

To help make the most of your precious time, I have reviewed a number
of titles in the past couple of years, like The
Peanuts, Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas, and The
Santa Clause. This year, there are a few more titles to consider,
so read on to find out which ones are worth your time, and which ones
you can leave wrapped on the shelf.

• Winnie the Pooh: Seasons of Giving


• Rolie Polie Olie: Olie’s Winter Wonderland


• Santa Clause 2


• A Christmas Story: 20th Anniversary Special Edition

Click to Buy	Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five)
	Audio		Video
	Goodies		Interface
	Value

The Disc

This compilation DVD features three Winnie the Pooh stories that appear
to be taken directly from the New Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
television series. The first episode is “Groundpiglet Day,”
which has Pooh and the gang searching for winter. The second episode is
“A Winnie the Pooh Thanksgiving,” and this one features several
songs, such as “The Turkey Song,” “Berrily We Roll Along,”
and “Our Thanksgiving Day.” The final episode is called “Find
Her, Keep Her,” and features Kessie the bluebird.

Promotional image © Disney.

Even though this disc is holiday themed, I just did not find the stories
or animation very compelling, and it did not capture the attention of
my two boys. In fact, my 5-year-old asked me why Rabbit looked green in
one scene and yellow in another, and that is pretty typical of the so-so
quality of these animated shorts. If you have never seen them, do not
expect much—but depending on the age and tastes of your children,
the animation may or may not be as much of a issue as it is for me.

The Goodies

There are only two activities on this disc. The first is a tree decorating activity that lets your children pick a type of tree and the decorations to put on it. My two boys played with the activities for about five minutes, and then wanted to move on to another disc.

Promotional image © Disney.

The Video, Audio, and Interface

As I mentioned earlier, the animation is not terribly impressive, and
the video transfer is no better than what you would see on the Disney
Channel or Toon Disney networks.

Be warned that the audio track listed on the back of the jacket is Dolby
Digital 5.1, but the DVD only provides a basic Dolby Digital 2.0 stereo
transfer—fortunately, this should be acceptable for the video’s intended
purpose.

The user interface and menus are easy to navigate and pretty standard
for Disney’s DVDs, and the menus feature animation, music, and animated
transitions.

Promotional image © Disney.

The Final Evaluation

This disc hosts mediocre animation and rather typical and rehashed Pooh
stories from the television series, and the only folks that will be seriously
interested in it are those Pooh fans who must have anything and everything
related to Pooh. For the rest of us, though, this will probably not put
you in a holiday mood, so pass on this one.

Click to Buy	Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five)
	Audio		Video
	Goodies		Interface
	Value

The Disc

This is another Disney holiday compilation disc, which features six
animated shorts from the Rolie Polie Olie television series—but
at least it does not pretend to be an all-new full-length movie. Among
the shorts, Olie and his family and friends meet with Klanky Klaus, have
fun with a snowman that comes to life, and visit a planet made of ice
cream.These shorts have all been presented on the television series, so
do not expect any new animation on this disc. If your children are familiar
with Olie, they will probably enjoy the shorts on this disc, but keep
in mind that they are not anything that you cannot find on Playhouse Disney.

The Goodies

There is only one goodie on the disc, and it was only of marginal interest
in my house. Olie’s Stocking Stuffer puts your children in charge of straightening
out the mixed-up presents and putting them in the correct stockings. Once
they are corrected, each box presents a brief trivia tidbit about how
different countries celebrate Christmas.

The Video, Audio, and Interface

Quite simply, since the source material is a television series, the video and audio transfers are equivalent to what you would see on cable or satellite, but not much more than that. The user interface on the disc, though, is quite nice and adds a nice touch to the whole package. Typical of other Olie discs, the menus feature a lot of animation, music, narrative audio, and animated transitions.

The Final Evaluation

Fans of Olie will probably enjoy the shorts on this disc the most, as
my two boys do, but since there is nothing new on the disc or any significant
bonus material, the disc is only worth a rental for your young viewers.

Click to Buy	Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five)
	Audio		Video
	Goodies		Interface
	Value

The Movie

In the first movie, The
Santa Clause, Scott Calvin, played by Tim Allen, becomes Santa
Claus through a strange but humorous twist of fate. This sequel takes
place eight years after that fateful evening, and Calvin has established
himself amongst his loyal elves as the best Santa ever. However, as the
holiday season begins to heat up, the problems start to arise. First,
his son ends up on his “Naughty” list, which puts him in quite
a bind. Then, the elves drop a bit of a bomb: the “Mrs. Clause”—he
only has a few precious weeks to find a wife before Christmas Eve or he
will stop being Santa forever. Top all that off with an overeager elf
who tries to help the situation by creating a duplicate Santa so the real
one can find a wife, but the duplicate goes a bit off the deep end and
threatens to ruin Christmas for children everywhere. Fortunately, like
any good family holiday movie, the movie wraps up with the anticipated
heartwarming conclusion.

Promotional image © Disney.

The Goodies

For a single disc “standard” release, this disc has a considerable
amount of bonus material, and while none of it is terribly in-depth, it
all works well and is very child-friendly. The way the bonus material
is presented is such that the movie was shot in the North Pole, and Santa
and his elves were kind enough to share their factory with the movie production
crew. The full-length commentary with Director Michael Lembeck is done
in a similar tone and is relatively interesting, but at times, it feels
a bit long and just a bit silly.

Promotional image © Disney.

The “Inside the North Pole” featurette with Curtis the elf
is cute, and my two young boys enjoyed it quite a bit. Curtis gives you
a personal behind-the-scenes tour of how Santa and his elves make magic
in the movies, and you get to see the elves going to school, finishing
up their makeup and more.

In a similar vein, the “True Confessions Of The Legendary Figures”
featurette shows interviews with the Tooth Fairy, Mother Nature, Father
Time and others as they talk about Santa and themselves. It, too, is kind
of cute, and is short enough to prevent it from growing a bit over done.

Promotional image © Disney.

Finally the two items that my boys enjoyed the most were the seven deleted scenes and the brief gag reel. Each of the deleted scenes include a very short introduction by Director Michael Lembeck, and they do a nice job of putting cut scenes into the context of the movie. The gag reel is simply a collection of flubs and missed lines, but it is fun to see, nonetheless.

The Video, Audio, and Interface

Since this is a relatively new movie, the THX-certified video and audio transfers are very good. The anamorphic widescreen video is spotless, and the Dolby Digital 5.1 audio is pleasantly spread around the room. As for the user interface, it is pretty standard for Disney DVDs. The animated menus and movie audio are perfectly themed, and they get you in the mood for the movie from the start.

Promotional image © Disney.

The Final Evaluation

This disc should definitely go on your list of movies for your family
to see this holiday season, but depending on how much you like The
Santa Clause, this may be only worth a rental rather than a purchase.

Click to Buy	Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five)
	Audio		Video
	Goodies		Interface
	Value

The Movie

After being around for 20 years, I think most of you have probably seen
A Christmas Story at one time or another. It is one of those quirky
movies that touches on every American holiday stereotype. Set in 1940s
Indiana and based on Jean Shepherd’s novel, “In God We Trust, All
Others Pay Cash,” the story follows a 9-year-old boy named Ralphie
as he works to get his one Christmas wish, a Red Ryder 200-shot Carbine
Action Air Rifle. However, among the cries of “You’ll shoot your
eye out!” Ralphie works every angle to beg and plead for his rifle,
and in the process, he battles a string of challenges to his quest, including
doubtful parents, a mean department store Santa, and school yard bullies.

The story is filled with holiday feelings and experiences that we have all periodically experienced in our lives, and when combined in this relatively slow-paced but heartwarming movie, you cannot help but get into the holiday sprit.

The Goodies

For a two-disc set, I cannot say that I was overly impressed with the
bonus material on this set. However, there is enough to make it worth
looking at if you do not already own the old DVD. Upgrading from the old
disc, though, will really depend on how much you really want the bonus
material.

On the first disc, there is only a humorous and informative commentary
by director/co-writer Bob Clark, and actors Melinda Dillon and Peter Billingsley.
It flows pretty well, and there are lots of funny behind-the-scenes stories
and tidbits that both fans and new viewers will enjoy.

The second disc contains several other goodies that are all worth looking
at, but they just feel a little light when compared to other two disc
special editions. There is a section where you can listen to several original
radio readings by author and movie narrator Jean Shepherd. These include
the original stories about the tongue on the flag pole and the Red Ryder
rifle. They are interesting to listen to, but children will probably not
be too interested in them.

There is also an 18-minute documentary on the making of the movie, which
features several new interviews with the grown actors and the production
crew. Even thought it is kind of short, it is fun to see and hear how
this classic was put together.

Finally, there are a couple of short featurettes on the Leg Lamp and
the Red Ryder rifle. The former looks at the ongoing impact that this
unique lamp has had since its first appearance 20 years ago, and the latter
looks at the history and current status of the Daisy Red Ryder air rifles
via a visit to the Daisy rifle factory.

The Video, Audio, and Interface

One of the main reasons that this set is spread over two discs is that the first disc contains both anamorphic widescreen and full-screen video transfers. For the most part, the video transfer is decent for this relatively old movie, but I did notice that the picture seemed a bit washed out and grainy. For the most part, these minor issues did not detract from enjoying the movie. As for the Dolby Digital 2.0 stereo audio transfer, there is not much to say other than it is completely adequate for its simple purpose. Finally, the user interface is well themed and executed, with animated snow flakes and audio and video clips from the movie. It is not the best presentation package I’ve seen for a special edition, but it works just fine.

The Final Evaluation

While not a movie for toddlers, this is one of those Christmas classics
that most people already have on their list of holiday “must-sees.”
If you have never seen this movie and are looking for a quirky, slice-of-life
Christmas movie, then definitely give this one a rent, and if you are
a big fan of the movie, then you will probably find buying this disc worth
it, especially if you don’t already have the old “movie-only”
DVD. Those thinking of upgrading will have to decide if the commentary
and about 30 minutes of extras are worth buying another copy. If I already
had a copy, I would probably rent the special edition for the bonus material
and just keep the old one.