DVD Review
The holiday season is upon us once again, and with that, we all begin
the hunt for the perfect gifts. DVDs have become prime gifts over the
last couple of years as DVD players have become incredibly affordable.
However, after a quick trip to your local discount store or a few minutes
browsing your favorite on-line retailer, you will see that choosing DVDs
these days has become quite a challenge. There are so many to choose from
that it will make your head spin, unless you are prepared. In order to
better prepare you and help you best spend your hard earned money, I have
assembled a slew of brief reviews of recent (and a few not so recent)
discs that you and your family may be thinking about for this season.
Family Flick Top Picks (click on a title to go to the review)
Stocking Stuffers and Lumps of Coal
- Bionicle 2: Legends of Metru Nui
- Mickey’s Twice Upon a Christmas
- Learning Adventures: Winnie the Pooh ABC’s and 123’s
- Gargoyles: The Complete First Season
- Ghosts of the Abyss
- The Black Hole
- Herbie Discs: Herbie Goes to Monte Carlo, Herbie Rides Again, and Herbie Goes Bananas
- Spy Kids Trilogy: Spy Kids, Spy Kids 2, and Spy Kids 3D: Game Over
| Mary Poppins: 40th Anniversary Edition (1964) | Approx. 139 min. | Rated G| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio |  | Video | | |
| Goodies |  | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
A few years ago, Disney released a “movie-only” DVD version of Mary Poppins, and I intentionally avoided it because I knew something better had to come along. Well, it has, and the wait was worth every month. The movie itself is an absolute classic that plays as well today as it did 40 years ago, and this two-disc 40th Anniversary Edition makes it shine. The THX certified audio and video transfer is fantastic. The Disney Enhanced Home Theater Mix soundtrack is lively and very enjoyable, and a scene like the firework shootout sounds pretty impressive. The original stereo soundtrack is also included, and sounds darn good, too.
Promotional image © Disney.
The video transfer is clean, detailed, and beautiful. The colors are solid and saturated, and the dark scenes show nice depth and clarity. For being 40 years old, this is an excellent presentation of the movie, and it is a treat to see it look and sound this good.
To top everything off, there is an awesome collection of bonus material,
including a wonderful 51-minute “Making of” documentary, some
cool reunion featurettes, and lots of music-related bonus material. Other
items you should not miss are the full-length commentary featuring Julie
Andrews, Dick Van Dyke, Karen Dotrice, Robert Sherman, and Richard Sherman,
the Gala World Premiere featurette, and the cute new animated short. This
collection is definitely worth adding to your home video collection, as
your whole family will not only enjoy the movie but also the wonderful
goodies.
| Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004) | Approx. 142 min. | Rated PG| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies |  | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
The third chapter in the ongoing saga of Harry Potter, wizard wunderkind,
has now made its way to DVD, and all of you Potter fans will be happy
to hear that it follows the successful trend of the previous two sets.
The movie, while yet again darker than the previous two, follows Harry
and the gang through their third year at Hogwarts, but this time Sirius
Black has escaped from the Azkaban wizard prison and is searching for
Harry. Even though the film’s director is different from the first two,
this movie nicely maintains the look and feel of the series. I will say
that it is not really a movie for the young ones in the family, but if
your children are old enough to read and appreciate the books, they should
be OK with the movie.
Given that this film was released earlier this year, I expected top-notch
video and audio transfers, and I was not disappointed. Quite simply, both
the video and audio transfers look and sound spectacular, and they should
play quite nicely on any home theater system.
Also, this two disc set features a good amount of bonus material. There
are a couple of brief behind-the-scenes featurettes worth watching, especially
if you are interested in how the production team makes thing happen. However,
the bulk of the bonus materials are interviews with the cast and crew,
so if you and/or your children enjoy about an hour of talking heads discussing
the movie, then you will definitely enjoy the material. I, however, found
some of the interviews less than enthralling and moved on. Overall, though,
the movie presentation is great and there is enough bonus material to
make this set worth picking up for most Potter fans. At the very least,
those of you that enjoy the movie should give the set a spin from your
local rental outfit.
| Miracle (2004) | Approx. 136 min. | Rated PG| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
I remember sitting in front of the TV during the 1980 Winter Olympics
and watching the United States Men’s Hockey team beat the “unbeatable”
Soviet Union team. It was quite an event, and earlier this year, the story
of the U.S. team was finally made into a film starring Kurt Russell as
Coach Herb Brooks. Watching the movie brought back a flood of memories,
names, and emotions that will put goose bumps on those of us that watched
those events unfold. It is also impressive how well the producers portray
the political climate, fashions, and game action, and it definitely adds
to the impact of the movie. [Read Alex Stroup’s movie review of Miracle
here.]
Although the movie may not hold the attention of younger children, it
is a pretty decent family movie with a great story that shows what hard
work can achieve.
Promotional image © Disney.
The DVD itself is a treat. The THX-certified anamorphic widescreen video
and Dolby Digital surround sound audio transfer faithfully reproduce the
film’s look, feel, and sound, and it will look and sound good on any home
theater. The video is clean and sharp, and the good ol’ reds, whites,
and blues (and other colors, too) are solid and beautifully detailed.
As for the audio, it, too, is right on target, and it provides plenty
of surround sound effects, especially during the game scenes.
Then, there is the solid collection of goodies that provides a good look
at not only the making of the movie but also the inspiration for it. Between
the audio commentary by Director Gavin O’Connor, Editor John Gilroy, and
Director of Photography Daniel Stoloff, the “Making of” featurette,
the “Sound of” featurette, and the “From Hockey to Hollywood”
featurette, you get a great idea of the incredible effort that went into
accurately reproducing such a memorable sporting moment. There is also
a cool ESPN roundtable discussion where several of the original team members
got together with Kurt Russell to discuss the team, the coach, and the
whole event. Also, the discussion between Herb Brooks and Kurt Russell
provides a unique and interesting look at what made Brooks tick.
Promotional image © Disney.
If you or someone in your family has any interest in sports movies, underdog movies, or just a good family movie about a team that achieves the impossible, this DVD is a must. You get a great movie, a wonderful presentation, and a fascinating collection of bonus material, and there is not much more to ask for. Even if you are not a huge sports fan, though, this DVD is well worth renting for a couple of nights.
| Bionicle 2: Legends of Metru Nui (2004) | Approx. 75 min. | Rated PG| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies |  | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
This prequel to last year’s Bionicle:
The Mask of Light follows a small group of Matoran as they
are turned into Toa to defend the city of Metru Nui against a mysterious
dark force. The movie is action packed, and it closely follows the look
and feel of the first movie. Also continuing the graphical style of the
original, the computer animation is pretty decent and features several
fascinating environments with all kinds of cool visual effects.
Promotional image © Disney.
The story, however, is probably more easily understood by your young
Lego maniacs than by yourself, as the world of Bionicle has been well
established via numerous toy sets, comic books, and online information.
If you are not very familiar with the terms, “Toa,” “Matoran,”
and “Kanoka Discs,” then you may not find the movie all that
interesting because you may get lost rather quickly. If you have a child
who loves Bionicle, they are sure to enjoy this movie, but be aware that
all the action may be a bit too intense for young children
As with the first DVD, this disc is real eye and ear candy. The movie covers a wide range of environments, and the colors and shadows, which range from very saturated, bright yellows, reds, blues, and greens (the traditional Lego colors) to dark grays and blacks, are solid and pleasing throughout. The Dolby Digital soundtrack sounds very nice and features plenty of surround effects. Overall, the presentation is a lot of fun to watch and listen to.
Promotional image © Disney.
There is a little bit of bonus material on this single disc worth mentioning, but it is light relative so some of the other titles in this review. For those of you that want to brush up on your history of the city of Metru Nui , there is an activity that lets you explore various aspects of the island and its inhabitants. Also, the “Making of” and “The Legend Revealed” featurettes provide enough background to appreciate the genesis of the movie, but they do not del ve into very many details.
Overall, this disc is a good choice for those steeped in Bionicle lore, but for the rest of you, you may want to save those pennies for something else.
| Mickey’s Twice Upon a Christmas (2004) | Approx. 68 min. | Rated G| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies |  | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
When I first watched the trailers for this, it made my eyebrow twinge.
I don’t know if it was just watching classic 2-D animated Disney characters
move across the screen as 3-D computer renditions, but they were not the
same characters I have known for years and years.
Promotional image © Disney.
So it was with some trepidation that my young boys and I popped this
disc into my player and started watching the five animated shorts that
make up this package feature. After about 10 minutes, my 6-year-old asked
if I could put something else on because, “this is boring.”
So much for thinking modern children will enjoy something because it is
computer animated. I put it away for a few days and then gave it another
try with my boys, and the second time around they seemed to be a wee bit
more receptive, but it was clear that it was not holding their attention.
The deleted scenes were marginally interesting, and the other two minor
goodies were uninspiring.
Promotional image © Disney.
I think between the mediocre stories and the radically different character
animation of universally familiar characters, this disc just does not
cut it. The video and audio transfers look and sound great, but all the
flash and bang in the world cannot make up for so-so content. Since the
first attempts at watching it with my boys, they have only asked once
to watch it again, and it was only to watch one of the five shorts. Save
your money on this one and put it towards Mary Poppins.
| Learning Adventures: Winnie the Pooh ABC’s and 123’s (2004) | Approx. 30 min. each | Not Rated | Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
On the young children’s end of the spectrum, Disney has collaborated
with educators to have Winnie the Pooh and friends teach 2- to 5 year-olds
about their ABC’s and 123’s. Each of the discs sports a 30-minute animated
story that features opportunities for the characters to count or identify
alphabetical characters. It is perfectly suited for the intended age group,
and if your young children enjoy Pooh and learning, then these discs are
well worth taking a look at.
| Gargoyles: The Complete First Season (1994) | Approx. 294 min. | Rated TV Y7| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
I know there is an audience for GargoylesGargoyles was going to be released
on DVD, and now your wait is over. The first season of this animated Disney
TV series is featured on this two disc set, and contains the following
episodes:
First Season: Disc 1
- Awakening: Part One
- Awakening: Part Two
- Awakening: Part Three
- Awakening: Part Four
- Awakening: Part Five
- The Thrill Of The Hunt
- Temptation
First Season: Disc 2
- Deadly Force
- Enter MacBeth
- The Edge
- Long Way To Morning
- Her Brother’s Keeper
- Reawakening
Staring a group of gargoyles that have been frozen in stone for 1,000
years on the moors of Scotland, the show starts off as they come back
to life in modern New York City and begin to explore their new world.
It is one of those shows that works on different levels, but its target
audience is really a bit older than one might expect. Because of its numerous
mythological and literary references, the show seems to have connected
with adults down to pre-teens, but it is probably a bit much for younger
children. I also think it is one of those cartoons that you need to spend
time with to begin to appreciate it, and this set is a good start to get
acquainted or re-acquainted with the story.
The 13 episodes are presented in full screen, and the video and audio
transfers are very basic. The video pretty much looks like an old TV cartoon,
and the audio is nothing more than what you would normally get from broadcast
television. It is not much, but it does the job.
The set contains a couple of goodies that fans will enjoy, especially the five audio commentaries for the first five episodes and the featurette on the “Gathering of the Gargoyles” annual fan meeting. The show pitch by creator Greg Weisman is also interesting but short. These too are not much, but they are enough to add some value to the set. In the end, though, the set is probably of most interest to fans of the TV series.
| Ghosts of the Abyss (2004) | Approx. 60 and 90 min. | Rated PG| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
I am probably one of a relatively small minority that never had any desire
to see James Cameron’s 1997 epic Titanic, but I am fascinated
by the events that took place and the technology that people are now using
to visit the hallowed resting site of that great ship. I have watched
several documentaries on the subject, but I have to admit that Ghosts
of the Abyss puts an interesting and personal spin on the Titanic
disaster.
Promotional image © Disney.
The movie follows Cameron, his friend (and Titanic cast) Bill
Paxton, and a crew of history and marine experts on a journey to explore
the Titanic wreck, inside and out. Using the latest robotic submersibles,
the team provides some amazing views of the massive ship. However, the
cool thing about this movie is that Cameron takes submersible images and
re-creates and overlays an accurate representation of what the scene looked
like before the ship sank. For example, the radio room, the engine room,
and the bridge are re-created and superimposed on the wreck, and each
of these scenes are personalized by a discussion of the people involved
with the events of that night. It makes for a fascinating history lesson.
The two-disc set features both 60- and 90- minute versions of the movie,
and there are two bonus items that are well worth watching. The 36-minute
documentary on the documentary, “Reflections From The Deep”
is a fun and interesting look at how Cameron and his crew put this whole
thing together. It also features footage of their dives that was cut from
the movie, and it ranges from pretty humorous to downright impressive.
Also on the set is a multi-angle look at one of the crew’s dives to the
Titanic. You can select from a variety of cameras on the submersible
and experience what it is like to dive to the bottom of the ocean.
Promotional image © Disney.
For anyone interested in the Titanic or deep sea exploration,
this set is an excellent choice, but even if you are not a huge Titanic
fan, it is still a good rental if you are looking for something a little
different that the family can sit down and watch together.
| The Black Hole (1979) | Approx. 98 min. | Rated PG| Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
For its time, The Black Hole—the first Disney movie to get
a PG rating—featured some of the most impressive visual effects ever
seen on the big screen. The only problem is that they are wrapped around
the rather odd story of a mad genius who has perched his ship, the U.S.S.
Cygnus, on the edge of a black hole. A small crew of explorers stumbles
upon this unusual ship and begins to unravel the bizarre plans of Dr.
Hans Reinhardt. Unfortunately, many of the effects do not stand up well
against today’s special effects, so younger viewers may be a bit hardened
and find this movie to look really phony. Then, there is the matter of
the story.
Promotional image © Disney.
The movie looks pretty good for being 25 years old, and the sound is
decent, which is about all I expected. The bonus material is almost non-existent,
but the 16-minute, behind-the-scenes featurette is marginally interesting
for any of you who remember watching this movie in the theaters. Overall,
this disc is only worth renting for those nights where you are looking
for a little blast from the past but not much else.
| Herbie Goes to Monte Carlo (1977) | Approx. 105 min | Rated G | Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | Interface | | ||
| Value | | |||
| Herbie Rides Again (1974) | Approx. 88 min | Rated G | Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | Interface | | ||
| Value | | |||
| Herbie Goes Bananas (1980) | Approx. 102 min | Rated G | Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | Interface | | ||
| Value | | |||
Ah, Herbie, the lovable Love Bug. I reviewed the original Love
Bug special edition DVD in the middle of last year, and that two-disc
set was really cool. Then, earlier this year Disney released the other
three Herbie movies as movie-only DVDs. While the audio and video transfers
are decent, the lack of bonus material pretty much puts these three discs
into the same “rental-only” category.
Promotional image © Disney.
Herbie goes to Monte Carlo is probably the best movie of the
three, so if you are trying to decide between them, start there and work
your way through the other two. All three of these are classic family
flicks, so next time you are in your local rental store looking for some
Saturday night movies, check one of these out. Just don’t expect anything
more from these DVDs than the movies.
| Spy Kids (2001) | Approx. 88 min | Rated PG | Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
| Spy Kids 2: Island of Lost Dreams (2002) | Approx. 100 min | Rated PG | Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
| Spy Kids 3D: Game Over (2003) | Approx. 84 min | Rated PG | Reviewed by Kevin Krock |
 Click to Buy | Ratings Summary (Scored out of a maximum of five) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | | Video | | |
| Goodies | | Interface | | |
| Value | | |||
Nobody in my family caught any of these three movies when they were in
the theaters, yet my 3- and 6-year-olds are absolutely fascinated by the
Spy Kids. Despite the fact that the two boys have only seen commercials,
McDonald’s comic books, and a couple of the bonus featurettes, they tell
me that both Carmen and Juni live somewhere in our house along with a
host of their other invisible friends. I guess the attraction to these
characters is their young age and daring high-tech adventures.
Promotional image © Disney.
The first movie, Spy Kids, is actually pretty good for both
adults and older children. The story is fun and action packed, and the
movie features a bunch of cool spy-tech gadgets that help the Spy Kids
save their international spy parents from the evil Fegan Floop.
Spy Kids 2: The Island of Lost Dreams takes the young spy duo
and their parents on a journey around the world to recover a device that
threatens the world, and even though this one is not quite as good as
the first, it is still pretty decent.
However, Spy Kids 3D falls way short and feels like a video
game that was never quite fleshed out or finished. There are 3D effects,
but I didn’t find them to add much to the movie. Also, just be aware that
in all three movies there are several action sequences and a considerable
amount of peril that Carmen and Juni are put in, so you may need to decide
how much of that your younger children can handle.
Regarding the presentation, it is pretty simple: All three of these DVDs
feature top-notch video and audio transfers. The anamorphic video transfers
should look great on any home theater system, and the Dolby Digital 5.1
surround sound soundtrack is very dynamic and enveloping.
Promotional image © Disney.
In terms of goodies, the Spy Kids disc is seriously lacking,
but it is a better movie and sort of offsets that deficiency. Spy
Kids 2 has a ton of stuff packed on to this single disc Collector’s
Series DVD. There is plenty of behind-the-scenes material, and I was particularly
impressed with the range and openness of the goodies. Robert Rodriguez
(Director/Writer/Producer) does a good job, not only with the movie but
also with the bonus material, of taking directly to the target audience
of middle schoolers while not excluding parents.
Finally, the Spy Kids 3D two-disc set has a good amount of bonus
material that is very similar to that on Spy Kids 2. It does
cover some interesting aspects of that movie, but you really have to like
the third movie to watch bonus material about it.
If you or your children are looking for a good family friendly adventure movie but you do not particularly care for bonus stuff, be sure to check out Spy Kids. Additionally, if your children enjoy the bonus material and want to see how these movies were put together, pick up Spy Kids 2 too. You can avoid Spy Kids 3D or just rent it, as the other two titles have better movies and more than adequate behind-the-scenes material.
